Scrolling down the list of starting pitchers, the feeling of calm and appeasement settles in. Why? The current state of the offense generates faint anxiety and a lack of confidence, however, the pitching is enough to keep our heads above water until the sticks wake up with consistency.
Two pitchers who have earned their jobs in this Blue Jays rotation are Chris Bassitt and Yusei Kikuchi. Both of these fine gentlemen offer substantial pitch-ability complimented by an artsy pallet of pitch options, and longevity to absorb quality innings. Both of these arms finished 2023 with success in their numbers and provided quality outings for the rest of the team to eat off of heading into a new season.
Chris Bassitt is a 35-year-old gem of a signing after he declined the New York Mets qualifying offer and inked a three-year deal with the Blue Jays in the 2022/2023 offseason. He brought his profile to Toronto and continued to execute in fashion. Last season, Bassitt tossed a total of 200 innings and faced 826 batters in 33 starts. His .667 win-loss percentage was a result of a 16-8 record, in which the wins were AL-leading.
Chris Bassitt records 200 innings in a season for the first time in his career (4th pitcher to reach that mark this year).
Last #BlueJays was Marcus Stroman in 2017
— Hazel Mae (@thehazelmae) September 29, 2023
Bassitt is very artistic when it comes to his offerings and repertoire which is what enhances his performances in every matchup he endures. Some go to Las Vegas to see magic shows, and some attend the Rogers Center to see Bassitt work magic using eight-pitch options to carve hitters. Sinker, cutter, curveball, sweeper, slider, split-finger, changeup, and a four-seam fastball are all of his pitch options. Five of the eight options have above a 15% put-away percentage. Five of the eight options have a value of 20+ strikeouts in 2023. This shows the effectiveness of each option, rather than just a working project pitch amongst some stronger offerings.
In 2023, Bassitt recorded a 3.60 ERA with 186 strikeouts and only 59 walks. Similar to Kevin Gausman, he does not allow a ton of free 90s. As we look forward to 2024, it is hard to see Bassitt sway away from this type of performance, however, the intelligence of his repertoire is noted and is somewhat common knowledge throughout the league. In addition to this, the potential of the lack of run support can reduce his projections to a 14-7 record with an ERA around 3.20 and a similar strikeout-to-walk rate. He’s also had a tough start to the season (7.71 ERA with eight earned so far), which he will need to overcome.
Yusei Kikuchi was another individual with similarities to Bassitt from a numbers perspective. He faced 700 hitters within 167 2/3 innings across 32 starts and produced a 3.86 ERA, a great bounce-back after his dreadful 2022 season. Kikuchi struck out 181 hitters while only walking 48 as well as using half of the pitch options that Bassitt works with, which is about average for a major league pitcher. His arsenal options are also very effective and well used, with three of the four pitches sitting above 15% put-away percentage last year and three of the four values finishing with 20+ strikeouts.
Yusei Kikuchi, 96mph 🧀 pic.twitter.com/JESdgK1OYI
— Rob Friedman (@PitchingNinja) April 5, 2024
Kikuchi is calculated in his counts and is smart in how he works batters. His knowledge of the hitters he faces and his abilities gives him an advantage through the majority of his matchups. He stays on top of the count, starting with a strike which equalled a 59.4% first-pitch strike rate in 2023. The deeper he gets into counts with advantage, the more wiggle room he has to execute his effective off-speed and breaking options.
Kikuchi’s projections for 2024 should be similar to 2023 in the strikeout categories as well as ERA. The win-loss category should be no less than 10 but possibly between 10-13 wins with 7-8 losses. So far he carries one loss with 11 strikeouts, five walks, and one no-decision through two starts in 2024.