D-Market Elektronik Hizmetler ve Ticaret A.S. (NASDAQ:HEPS) Q3 2023 Earnings Conference Call December 5, 2023 8:00 AM ET
Company Participants
Helin Celikbilek – Investor Relations Director
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin – Chief Executive Officer
Seçkin Köseoglu – Vice President of Strategic Finance
Conference Call Participants
Kilickiran Hanzade – JPMorgan
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by. I am Mina, your Chorus Call operator. Welcome, and thank you for joining the Hepsiburada Conference Call and Live Webcast to present and converse the Third Quarter 2023 Financial Results. All participants will be in a listen-only mode, and the conference is being recorded. The presentation will be followed by a question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions]
At this time, I would appreciate to turn the conference over to Mrs. Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin, CEO; Mr. Seçkin Köseoglu, Vice President of Strategic Finance; and Mrs. Helin Celikbilek, Investor Relations Director.
Mrs. Celikbilek, you may now proceed.
Helin Celikbilek
Thanks, operator. Thank you for joining us today for Hepsiburada’s third quarter 2023 earnings call.
I’m pleased to be joined on the call today by our CEO, Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin, and our Vice President of Strategic Finance, Seçkin Köseoglu.
The following discussion, including responses to your questions, reflects management’s views as of today’s date only. We embark on no obligation to update or revise this information except as required by law.
Certain statements made on today’s call are forward-looking statements and actual results may differ materially from these forward-looking statements. Please refer to today’s earnings release as well as the risk factors described in the Safe Harbor slide of today’s supplemental slide deck, today’s press release, the 6-K, our Form 20-F filed with the SEC on May 1, 2023, and other SEC filings for information on factors that could provoke our results to differ materially from these forward-looking statements.
Also, we will reference certain non-IFRS measures during today’s call. Please refer to the appendix of our supplemental slide deck as well as today’s press release for a presentation of the most directly comparable IFRS measures and the relevant IFRS to non-IFRS reconciliation.
As a reminder, a replay of this call will be available on our Investor Relations website.
And with that, I will hand it over to our CEO, Nihan.
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
Thank you, Helin. Welcome everyone, and thank you for joining us. I’m pleased to be with you today and to present our quarterly progress.
In Q3, amidst continued challenging macroeconomic environment where yearly inflation scaled to 61.5%, we delivered a robust financial performance. Our GMV more than doubled by 126% growth year-on-year. Adjusted for inflation, our GMV growth remained solid at 45% year-on-year.
The operational agility, afforded by our strategy, led to an outstanding performance that exceeded expectations. Our orders numbered 27 million. It was up 55% year-on-year, confirming a continuous demand for our differentiated services.
With an 11.6% gross contribution margin and through frugal OpEx management, our EBITDA as percentage of GMV rose by 690 basis points year-on-year to 2.7%. Adjusting for one-time other income, our quarterly EBITDA guidance was still 2.2%.
Our Hepsiburada Premium program has over 2 million members as of November-end, aligned seamlessly with our expectation. The program continues to play a pivotal role in elevating our order frequency and improving our customer retention.
Overall, I am very pleased to show sustainable growth and improved profitability.
Let me now take you through our delivery versus Q3 guidance. Through diligent execution, we surpassed our guidance for both GMV and EBITDA. Our GMV growth exceeded guidance by 16 percentage points. This performance was a result of our solid strategy that boosted loyalty to our platform. On top, in July, the announcement of the VAT enhance across all goods and services triggered a higher demand for e-commerce.
Furthermore, through prudent cost management, our EBITDA as a percentage of GMV reached 2.2%, adjusted for one-off income. This doubling of the upper-end of our EBITDA guidance clearly highlights our operational efficiency. The quarterly performance validates our commitment to sustainable growth and positions us favorably to achieve a positive full-year ’23 EBITDA on an unadjusted basis.
Hepsiburada is the key trust brand for e-commerce. In-line with our pledge to customer centricity, we announced HepsiburadaPromise initiative as a marketing campaign. As part of this initiative, we promoted key consumer benefits that encompasses next-day delivery ensure, convenience return pick-up services from consumer doorsteps, and an assurance of authenticated products.
To drive higher engagement, we partnered with one of Turkiye’s most confident inspiring celebrity for this initiative. We believe this initiative addresses the primary concerns of Turkish e-commerce consumers while underscoring our commitment to confront their expectations. This commitment is clearly reflected in our KPIs. 59% growth in order frequency, 55% order growth demonstrate that our consumer engagement and loyalty strategy is clearly working.
In the third quarter, with over 101,000 active merchant base, our total SKU count climbed to nearly 211 million. Our merchants can now [indiscernible] create coupons, which are a proven attraction point for customers. Self-management of campaigns, coupons and all advertising facilities drive higher conversion to sales for our merchants.
On top, we advanced our operations with automated inclusion of products in the next-day delivery coverage. This benefitted customers while freeing our merchants of a manual process. In our commitment to elevating the visibility and achieve of our merchants, we reintroduced our advertising solutions in a more effective format this quarter. These initiatives emphasize our commitment to a deeper merchant relationship as we help them grow their volume on Hepsiburada.
As always, we remain focused on execution excellence and our recent results affirm the effectiveness of our four-pillar strategy. Just to recap briefly, our strategy centers around loyalty, cultivating our sustainable differentiator, streamlining our costs, and expanding our B2B revenue in fintech and logistics. In the next few slides, I’ll supply a snapshot of our progress, highlighting our key achievements.
First, our Hepsiburada Premium program is a key loyalty driver and continues to gain momentum and exceeded 2 million members by end of November. The program success goes beyond [mere] (ph) expansion. It significantly influences customer behavior. Premium members’ monthly order frequency rose from 1.8 to 2.6 after they joined the program. This emphasizing the program’s potential to position Hepsiburada as customers’ go-to-e-commerce platform. The program’s quarterly net promoter score remained at a robust 81 points, which is 10 points above our overall NPS. We remain dedicated to keep this program as a compelling proposition for our members.
Let’s now look into one of our key differentiator, Hepsipay. In today’s economic landscape, affordability takes center stage, and our in-house fintech expertise clearly sets us apart. Leveraging our unique e-money payment services license, we offer a comprehensive suite of payments and affordability solutions. These include our prepaid card, Buy Now Pay Later solution, top-up to wallet loans, and point of sale shopping loans. A noteworthy addition is the Hepsipay prepaid cards in collaboration with Visa. We are encouraged by the demand for this card with 708,000 cards issued in just six months. Hepsipay card users can earn 3% cash back in all their online and in-store payments if they are a Premium program number.
A tool that customers use to top up their prepaid card is a general purpose loan from our partner banks, which can be reached with one-click solution from our app. This quarter, we integrated four major banks. Hepsipay wallet gives customers the freedom to spend these loans everywhere, both physical stores and online, combined with the ease of QR payments. With our customer centricity, our commitment to deliver stronger tailored payment and affordability solutions remains firm.
Next, let’s consider our affordability solutions, highlighting some performance indicators. The quarterly share of total non-card affordability solutions in our GMV was 5.6%, up from 5% a quarterly ago. This increased penetration is a result of our improved incorporation of non-card affordability solutions throughout our [buy] (ph) journey. Over the last 12 months, 762,000 orders came through this affordability solution.
As to our BNPL solution, Hepsiburada remains the first provider of Turkish e-commerce. Since its inception, over 245,000 customers have utilized their BNPL limits. In September, during iPhone 15 launch, we were the only platform to offer a BNPL solution for this high-value item.
I would appreciate to proceed to now our next differentiator, HepsiJet. HepsiJet’s strong NPS of 86.2 in Q3 underscores it acknowledged service excellence. HepsiJet continues to invest in expanding its geographical coverage by additional municipalities. Total municipalities covered exceeded 600 by the end of the quarter.
In Q3, HepsiJet continued its strong next-day delivery performance with 82% ratio among our 1P orders. Out of the total parcel volume on our platform, HepsiJet delivered 67%, confirming its integral role in our delivery ecosystem. Notably, HepsiJet XLarge delivered 57% of our oversized parcels. This is confirming greater merchant preference for our 2-Man-Handling capability.
In Q3, as a result of all our actions, we saw continued progress in profitability, posting a 2.2% EBITDA as percentage of GMV excluding the one-off item. The positive [indiscernible] clearly demonstrates the effectiveness of our strategy, confirming our core strength and our diligent cost management.
Now, let me take you through the fourth pillar of our strategy, which is generating B2B revenue from fintech and logistics. First, let’s start with HepsiJet. We continue to extend our external customer base, adding other retailers and doubling our customer count and doubling our volume year-on-year. This is confirming our ability to create B2B revenues of platform and clearly showcases HepsiJet’s strong momentum as an appealing logistic partner.
Now, let’s turn our eyes on Hepsipay’s off-platform expansion, enabling a [swift] (ph) payment go through. Hepsipay offers a one-click check-out solution: Pay with Hepsipay to other retailers. This solution became available at the online check-out of five major Turkish retailers in Q3, as seen on the slide. A leading Turkish home appliance brand, Karaca, leading Turkish fashion brand, DeFacto, leading baby brand, Ebebek, is just few of the examples.
Moreover, we also offer our lending capabilities as part of Hepsipay’s one-click check-out solution. This take-up aligns with our vision of providing fast, reliable, versatile payment and lending go through beyond Hepsiburada platform. Hepsipay’s features extend beyond one-click check-out. The seamless use of pay — prepaid cards both online and in-store payments clearly diversify our payment options for consumers.
The top-up to wallet with loans offer enables users to top-up their wallet with general purpose loans from multiple partner banks. These funds are then available to spend anywhere that accepts QR payment in addition to platforms with Hepsipay at their check-out. An upcoming feature is the integration of shopping malls within the Pay in Hepsipay network.
Before I dive into Q4 outlook, let me take a moment to talk about our November campaign performance. Our business is characterized by strong Q4 seasonality appreciate all other e-commerce players. We deliver a higher sales volume during the fourth quarter of the year. Our preliminary results indicates that this year we delevered yet a another very strong performance in November. We doubled the GMV compared to the same period last year. The number of orders was 2 times that of the monthly average of the prior month in ’23.
Our platform attracted almost 500 million visits and we sold over 30 million pieces. Our affordability solutions and loyalty program were particular attraction points. 46% of GMV generated through sales with credit cards came through installment sales. The most significant [service in] (ph) orders compared to the same period of last year were among clothing, appliance, home garden and FMCG.
We greatly welcome the consumer appreciation of our superior services, solutions, and campaigns in the busy month of November, where Hepsiburada clearly puts its name to the word legendary, which was created by us seven years ago.
And now, I want to close my presentation with our guidance. So, with another robust Legendary November behind us, we expect to deliver a solid and profitable growth also in fourth quarter. Accordingly, we expect to deliver a GMV growth within a range of 93% to 95% compared to the same period last year and EBITDA as a percentage of GMV within a range of 0.5% to 1%. These figures are unadjusted for inflation.
Consequently, for the full-year ’23, we expect to double our GMV year-on-year on an unadjusted basis and deliver EBITDA as a percent of GMV at 1.5%. These figures are also unadjusted for inflation.
With this, I thank you for listening, leave the floor to Seçkin, our forthcoming CFO, for more color on our Q3 financial performance. Then, I’ll do my closing remarks.
Seçkin Köseoglu
Thank you, Nilhan, and welcome, everyone.
It’s a pleasure to confront with all of you today for the first time. As I embark on my new role as CFO, I look forward to many more such occasions.
Despite the prevailing macroeconomic challenges, I am pleased to say that we continued our uptrend across all metrics during the third quarter. Unadjusted for inflation, our GMV rose 126% in quarter three on a yearly basis to TRY24.3 billion. Similarly, our IAS 29-unadjusted revenue growth was at 137% on a yearly basis. When adjusted for inflation, GMV and revenue growth were at 45% and 52%, respectively.
Strong order growth coupled with faster than inflation rise in the average order value and a strong e-commerce market growth in July on the back of a VAT rise resulted in a 126% GMV growth. The gross contribution margin came in at 11.6% on a 1.8 percentage point improvement on the same quarter of last year. Adjusted for inflation, this metric rose to 9.4% on a 1 percentage point improvement.
Quarter three was the third consecutive quarter of positive EBITDA unadjusted for inflation. Accordingly, our EBITDA as a percentage of GMV reached 2.7% on a 6.9 percentage point rise year-over-year. Excluding the impact of one-off income item, our EBTIDA as a percentage of GMV was at 2.2%. Also, when adjusted for inflation, this metric was at 0.3% on a 6.2 percentage point improvement year-over-year.
On the next slide, let’s elaborate on our GMV growth performance. 45% of GMV growth came through 27 million orders in quarter three. This performance results from our value proposition supported by the Hepsiburada Premium loyalty program and our affordability solutions. Our digital products contributed to the order frequency of participating customer segments. Yet, excluding these orders, our order growth was still strong at around 18%.
During the third quarter, we saw a 2.7 percentage point shift in GMV mix towards 1P. While we continue our growth in non-electronics, during this quarter, we also leveraged our strong 1P model to confront the demand in the electronics market.
On the next slide, I will converse our revenue and gross contribution performance. First, I would appreciate to give some color on revenues. Revenue growth of around 52% was achieved mainly by a 50% rise in retail revenue and 61% growth in marketplace revenue. Our retail and marketplace operations comprise 87% of our revenues. Our delivery service revenue, comprising 10% of total revenue, rose 43% compared to quarter three 2022. Meanwhile, other revenue, which mainly consists of our advertising services, fulfillment services, and loyalty program subscription fees, grew by 116% compared to quarter three 2022.
Our quarter three gross contribution margin was at 9.4% on a 1 percentage point improvement on the same quarter last year. This was mainly attributable to a higher re-discount impact on cost of inventory sold due to purchases on credit, a change in the 3P GMV category mix towards higher margin products, and a higher other revenue stream. Faster inventory turnover partially compensated for the margin deteriorating impact of significantly higher quarterly inflation that we have witnessed in quarter three.
Let’s proceed on to the EBITDA performance on the next slide. Together with strong top-line growth, our focus on costs and marketing spend optimization enabled us to deliver positive EBITDA for yet another quarter. The 6.2 percentage point year-over-year improvement in EBITDA as a percentage of GMV was mainly due to a 1 percentage point rise in gross contribution margin, 1.1 percentage point reject in advertising expenses, 0.1 percentage point reject in shipping and packaging expenses, 0.6% reject in payroll and outsourced stuff expenses, and 3.3% improvement in other OpEx items, which includes the settlement contribution from TurkCommerce in the quarter three this year and the provision expense related to the same litigation in quarter three of last year.
OpEx as a percentage of GMV was 9.1% in this quarter, thus 5.1 percentage points lower compared to 14.2% in the third quarter of last year. Our continued efficiency in marketing spend was achieved through our focus on customer retention and loyalty strategy, data-driven marketing, and co-marketing partnerships.
Next, a few words on our cash flow dynamics. Compared to quarter three 2022, our cash flow from operating activities increased by almost TRY1.4 billion to TRY2.2 billion in quarter three ’23. This enhance in cash flow from operating activities mainly resulted from a TRY1.1 billion improvement in EBITDA; TRY1.2 billion decrease in change in networking capital, mainly due to enhance in BNPL receivables and an enhance in inventory in anticipation of high demand in quarter four; TRY0.7 billion enhance in operating monetary gains due to inflation accounting and other items; and finally, TRY0.8 billion enhance due to realized FX gains. CapEx was around TRY234 million at 0.9 percentage point of GMV. Overall, our free cash flow was a positive TRY2 billion in quarter three 2023.
Before we end our call, I would appreciate to leave the word back to Nilhan to highlight the key takeaways from today’s presentation.
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
Thank you, Seçkin.
In Q3, we delivered a strong top-line growth and EBITDA through diligent cost management, exceeding our guidance. Our IAS 29-unadjusted GMV growth marked the highest quarterly growth since our IPO. On the margin side, we improved our gross contribution margin by 1.8 percentage points and EBITDA as a percent of GMV by 6.9 percentage points. We generated a substantial improvement in free cash flow on a yearly basis, thanks to our improvement in operating profitability. We are committed to creating long-term value for all our stakeholders and we work diligently to deliver our best possible results with our whole team. And finally, I take this opportunity to wish everyone seasonal greetings.
Thank you for listening. We can now open the line for questions.
Question-and-Answer Session
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, at this time, we will begin the question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] The first question — I am so sorry, there was a question but it was withdrawn. [Operator Instructions]
Ladies and gentlemen, there are no audio questions at this time. We will now proceed with the webcast questions from our participants. The first webcast question is from Maxim Nekrasov with Citi, and I quote, “What drives growth deceleration in Q4 2023 compared to third quarter 2023?” Thank you.
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
This is Nilhan speaking. We have couple of factors. One of them is our base in Q4 ’22 was extremely strong. That’s number one driver. Number two driver is, in Q3, Maxim, we had a VAT change, as I explained in July. This accelerated our growth as e-com platforms, which won’t be repeated from our expectations in Q4. And lastly, with the rising interest rates, we are expecting also some minor impact to the demand in Turkish markets. Hence, with these three, our expectation is the GMV growth [indiscernible].
Operator
[Operator Instructions] The next webcast question is from Ulle Adamson with T. Rowe Price, and I quote, “Any thoughts on possible local listings to improve the liquidity of shares?”
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
A local possible listing in Istanbul Stock Exchange is one of the ideas that we are always evaluating appreciate other options. There are pros and cons we are investigating, Ulle. As we crystallize our thinking, if there is something to share, we will obviously come back. But this is one of the things we are obviously looking into based on the feedback we received today.
Operator
[Operator Instructions] The next webcast question is from Tim Raschuk with Frontaura Capital, and I quote, “Hi. Could you please — excuse me, could you supply me color on September sales and how the Legendary November event was relative to your expectations? Thank you.”
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
It was almost spot on versus our expectations in November. We have done a couple of assumptions for November growth. One of them was increased uptake from our Premium consumers. Both our Premium membership enhance and the frequency enhance from Premium consumers has been in-line with our expectations. Non-electronic, new categories that we have been driving have been strong, that has also been in-line with our expectations. And in terms of our marketing scheme, the number of sessions we planned for Legendary November also was in-line with our expectations. So, I would say we invented Legendary November seven years ago and since then we have been getting stronger and stronger in our execution. And in-line with our plans, we delivered a strong November campaign.
Operator
Our next webcast question is from Christian Andrews with Frontaura Capital, and I quote, “Digital orders represented a significant portion of order growth. Could you extend on what these orders associate to and would their contribution to revenue growth be similar?
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
The digital orders, yes, they represent significant portion of order growth, but in terms of GMV, it’s immaterial. It’s less than 0.7% of our GMV. So, we can’t talk about any related contribution to our GMV growth. It’s strategic. It drives frequency. It drives consumers to come back, create loyalty retention. So, we’ll continue driving that.
Operator
Thank you. We also have a question from [Mr. Hassan Bayahan] (ph), and I quote, “How do you invest in the U.S. cash you have? What is the return on that?”
Seçkin Köseoglu
Hi. We typically use time deposits in banks. And I think the yield is the question, we are close to 5% on our yield for USD deposits.
Operator
Thank you. The next question is from Mr. Maxim Nekrasov with Citi, and I quote, “What are your expectations regarding consumer demand in 2024 considering recent interest hikes?”
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
Our progress and results clearly demonstrate that our strategy works in ’23. And as we look forward to the coming year, although the interest rate increases could diminish consumer demand, consumption can also impact Turkish economic growth, we have several key initiatives reinforcing our position. I preserve our commitment to strategic priorities, affordable shopping options, benefits from Premium program, and also e-com is in best place, [very suited] (ph) to serving consumers in this type of environment.
Operator
Our next webcast question is a follow-up from Mr. Ulle Adamson with T. Rowe Price, and I quote, “What is the outlook for EBITDA margin in 2024? Also, where would you appreciate to see the margin over the longer term?”
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
For 2024, we are going to talk about our guidance, our expectations as part of our Q4 earnings result. But what I can say, we are extremely committed to sustainable, profitable growth. We have built a very strong initiative pipeline for ’24 and also upcoming years in-line with the presentation we have done, that is including Hepsi advertising platform, that’s including non-electronics in our mix, that is including incremental margin from our services and B2B revenues that will continue to improve our margin situation. For granular details and expectations, we’ll come back in Q4.
Operator
Thank you. Our next webcast question is from Christian Andrews with Frontaura Capital, and I quote, ” Hepsi Premium reached 2 million members. Could you please speak a bit about any targets for the program? Is there a target number of members? Is this program breakeven yet on a consolidated basis?”
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
In terms of Hepsiburada Premium program, obviously, we are quite bullish about creating a great, amazing program that will be sticky for our consumers. We are not chasing a specific number. We are looking into sustainable profitability of the company, sustainable profitable growth using loyalty retention initiatives in a mix that also includes Premium. Hence, I’m not going to share a specific number that we are chasing for next year, but we will continue to improve both the benefits of the program and also numbers in the program.
In terms of premium Profitability, we don’t share the details for a specific consumer segment. In future, we could look into giving different cuts in our profitability, but so far, we are only sharing a consolidated view.
Operator
Our next question is an audio question from the land of Kilickiran Hanzade with JPMorgan. Please go ahead.
Kilickiran Hanzade
Nilhan and Seçkin, apologies, I had a technical issue. I couldn’t ask my question initially. I would appreciate to follow up on the gross contribution margin. You have a very strong, I mean, robust improvement here. Would it be reasonable to say that some — I mean, large part of this expansion in the gross margin contribution comes from the inventory gains? Because there was a very high inflation in the third quarter and I just tried to grasp whether this expansion is one-off or not. And — or otherwise, have you observed some structural changes in your business appreciate a higher share of clothing category or better take rates that may continue to uphold the margins going forward?
And the second question is, is it possible to supply some sort of update on the recent competition authority investigation? What it is about? And do you expect some negative results from this investigation? Thank you.
Seçkin Köseoglu
Yes, as I mentioned in my presentation, the re-discount impact on cost of inventory sold due to purchases on credit has an impact on the improvement in gross contribution. But the key structural improvement that we are making are related with the 3P GMV category mix towards higher margin product. And this is going to continue in the future as well. And definitely other revenue stream is something that we are continuing to extend, especially a word of note, our Premium fees, our HepsiAd, which is very important for our future profitability, and the expansion of our delivery services. So, these are structural key interventions that we will be continuing to have in the coming quarters as well.
Nilhan Onal Gökçetekin
Let me come back on the second question, which is the competitive authority investigation. There has been an investigation in Turkey for price recommendations for merchants from e-commerce platforms. We have been one of the companies that competition authority wanted to better grasp the logic. We have been sharing all the data we have. This is a recent capability we developed in order to improve merchants’ competitiveness, in order to improve competitive prices with right ambition, with right material. So, we are very comfortable in terms of the potential outcome. There could be a situation, Hanzade, in the worst case scenario, the competition authorities could say, “We would appreciate platforms to hold this application,” but nothing beyond that. So, even the worst case scenario, obviously we are ready for this, but we wouldn’t suggest it.
Kilickiran Hanzade
Thank you very much.
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, there are no advance questions at this time. The conference is now concluded, and you may disconnect your telephone. Thank you for calling, and have a good afternoon.
